Friday, January 4, 2019
The Russian Revolution
a) From line A I canister learn that the tsar was bunglesome and disorganised, as source A states Nicholas II was very(prenominal) poorly vigilant for the responsibilities of cosmos the tzar.. I can in like manner learn that due to the tsars ignorance of politics and the tidy sum of Russia, he couldnt make the right decisions to befriend the sphere. showtime A alludes that Tsar Nicholas II wasnt very popular, due to the fact he didnt know how to run the country or help the raft in motivating of financial and medical project (the bring down classes and peasants). I can also suggest from root A that the whole country was in disarray, that no-one was equal because Tsar Nicholas II didnt know how to run the country or make the desperately needed decisions that would social welfare the country as a whole.b) starting time C and A support distri exactlyively take issueent because both state that Tsar Nicholas II was unfit to reign Russia. They discordentiate that h e was ignorant of the necessary familiarity required to rule the country, this ignorance was the key movement for his downfall. However they both differ slightly. antecedent C says that the fact Tsar Nicholas II was useless as a prescript was non his fault he was apparently intelligent, faithful and courageous but was all told ignorant of government publications. The source was interpreted out of the Tsars babes diary, so she, no matter how bad things got with the Tsar, would placid stick up for him. Whereas spring A is taken from a textbook pen about Russia, because they need not show either compassion for the Tsar so they can write just the facts. commencement C and B support all(prenominal) other because in source C the Tsars sister says that the Tsar was still popular in the days before 1914 and in source B it shows a photograph of Tsar Nicholas II with is many supporters celebrating the 300 years of rule of the Romanov family, showing that he still had support when the picture was taken in 1913. stem C and B differ from each other because in semen C, the Tsars sister says that Nicholas wasnt a good pattern of Russia, and that he was trained as a soldier not as a statesman. Yet in Source B, he is shown surrounded by his many supporters blissful him and his whole family. Surely if they didnt like him accordingly they wouldnt be happy he was in power, (however, there are probably but the upper classes involved in the solemnisation as the Tsar hasnt done anything to passion them whereas he didnt treat the lower classes easily at all.)Overall I weigh that that Source A and C support each other the most as both say that the Tsar was incompetent as a ruler of Russia, and differ from each other only very slightly. Furthermore I think that Source B and C differ from each other the most because in Source C the Tsars sister says that he wasnt a very good ruler and in Source B he is being shown as a great ruler surrounded by his cheering su pporters.c) I can learn from source D that the behavior Tsar dealed with those who opposed his way of ruling the country was with violence and death. As Source D shows strikers killed by the law of nature. This Source is reliable because it is a photograph, and you can count the workers dead on the ground and police members standing round them. It could be a hoax, with people pretending to be dead, but is highly unlikely to be one.I can learn from Source E that the people felt that the government was not making the right choices, and that they were being forced into forming revolutionary groups by the government. This sources reliability could be questioned as it was written by a party opposing the Tsar as a legal transfer, so the aim of the speech was to turn people against the current tzarist government and to support theirs. Also, as it was written as a speech its meant to dribble and motivate the listeners, so some aspects of it whitethorn have been exaggerated.Overall, I think that Source E is more useful in telling us how discontented the people were with the Tsarist government, as its more fine in its explanation and shows human emotion on the situation. However, I believe that Source D is the more reliable of the both as, because its a photo, we can be reliable the events captured on film actually happened.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
No comments:
Post a Comment